Help Support Us
PARENTING QUESTIONS-
SMART LOVE ANSWERS

Click on your selection below for answers to common parenting questions
and concerns at each stage of development. To get more answers click
here to purchase Parenting Questions-Smart Love Answers.


Please click on your selection below:


TODDLER Q&A




Time-outs and other disciplines are power tools.

I understand that spanking children is bad because it teaches them it is 
OK to inflict physical pain on others. But I really don't understand why you 
say that other disciplinary responses when children do something wrong, 
such as time-outs or taking away privileges like talking on the phone, are 
not OK. These responses do seem to work and I can't see they are harming 
my children. Could you please explain your position? 

C.T., Wheaton


Don't forget discipline works only because we are bigger and stronger and 
because we control the resources they need. Given that the ultimate basis 
for our ability to manage our children's behavior is power, and given all 
children copy the way their parents treat them, how we use the power we 
have will shape the way our children treat themselves and how they treat 
others. Time-outs and consequences are emotionally harsh even though 
they are not physically violent. When children copy these strategies for 
handling differences of opinion, they may become adults who withdraw 
from relationships when the other  disagrees with them or who use money 
or other material goods in controlling, punitive ways. This is why we 
advocate loving regulation as a way of managing children's behavior. In 
loving regulation, the parent steps in and regulates the behavior without 
ever adding unpleasant consequences such as time-outs. Loving regulation 
is nonviolent parenting; in this increasingly violent world, we need to raise 
our children to be adults who can tolerate others' differences without 
resorting to violence-physical or emotional. 
Martha Heineman Pieper, Ph.D., and William J. Pieper, M.D., 2010 ©. All rights reserved.
Smart Love Family Services • Chicago, Illinois • P:773.665.8052 • E: contact@smartlovefamily.org
©2010 Smart Love Family Services. All rights reserved.